One night, writer Victor Fiorillo stopped by the Old Philadelphia Bar hoping for a beer and some company. Before entering, a sign on the window caught his attention: “If you’re not proud to be an American, do not bother to come in.” Curious, Fiorillo went inside anyway. Soon after, a man heading toward the jukebox announced loudly that he was a former firefighter and a Mexican—before laughing and saying the last part was a joke.

He then played Lee Greenwood’s 1984 hit, “God Bless the USA.” As the chorus filled the bar, nearly everyone joined in singing. The bar has long been a neighborhood staple, known for cheap drinks, classic décor, and a proudly old-school atmosphere. Management says the sign is simply meant to set expectations: patrons should be prepared for overt patriotism.

The bar also brands itself as “hipster-free,” catering to longtime locals rather than newcomers. When a photo of the sign surfaced in a local Facebook group, backlash followed. Some residents felt the message was exclusionary or unwelcoming, particularly toward minorities.

One woman said she would avoid the bar because her boyfriend is Indian and bearded, saying the sign made her uneasy. Staff members, however, defended the message, insisting it was being misunderstood. “If you’re in this country, you should be proud to be an American,” one bartender said. The sign continues to spark debate. What do you think?